Aunt Anne’s is the one of the left. Pecan Sandy is the on the right, which is stolen from Better Home and Gardens, Dec 12.
So this recipe is doubly-stolen. You’re getting it because I broke into my Great Aunt’s house one day (okay I was cat-sitting). I copied this recipe which she has refused to give out to anyone else in the family… ever. Not even my grandmother (her sister) has it and so far noone has found out that I make it for friends in the safety of my own kitchen under the cover of night.
Aunt Anne stole it from a classy resturant by flirting with a waiter. And no, she was not a young woman at the time. She was an over-weight Italian woman in her mid-fifties, so we’re not sure if he gave it to her out of genuine attraction, or if the cook was flattered when the waiter uncomfortably regaled her with the story of the woman asking to sit in his lap while he whispered his culinary secrets, or if the waiter was just terrified that she’d come back and keep harassing him.
Either way, the cookies are great.
1 ib of sweet butter, chilled (that’s generally 4 sticks for the mathematically lazy and/or challenged)
6 egg yolks
1 tablespoon of lemon juice
5 cups of flour
1/2 cup of granulated sugar
1) Sift 5 cups of flour and 1/ cup of sugar in a large bowl.
2) Cube 1 ib of butter into small peices. Mix with the sifted flour and sugar.
3) Work by hand into the mixture until evenly dispersed (crumb-like).
4) Make a well and add all the liquids (6 egg yolks and 1 tbs lemon juice).
5) Form into a ball (a sticky hot mess of a ball) and chill for an hour.
6)Preheat oven to 350.
7) Roll out the dough to a thickness of 1/8 inch. Cut out a circle for the bottom and top. Seperate an equal number of tops from bottoms. Then cut out the hearts (I’m trying really hard not to make any inappropriate sex jokes about this, which I guess is just proof that we all turn into our parents).
8) Mysteriously missing step? Or nervous waiter numbering wrong? The world may never know…
9) Bake for 12 minutes.
10) Cool cookies. Spread jam onto bottom. Dip top into confectionary sugar and make into sandwich.
Aunt Annie has not revealed to us the type of jam in the sandwich. I’m fairly sure, it’s raspberry, but I’ve used strawberry, rubarb, and blueberry.
Tips and Notes:
If you plan on making the cherry macaroons, save the egg whites from this recipe.
The first time I made this, I got holy-shit confused over the well thing. You basically lump all the dry mix into a mountain, and dig a hole at the top. Then pour the wet stuff into it. You then fold the wet into the dry. I have no idea why the well is important; one of the disadvantages to stealing recipes is that I have never been properly instructed on the nuances of dough-wells. By the way, you’ll get very sticky while making these cookies; but I promise it’s worth it.
Cutting out the hearts… This requires a special kind of cookie cutter. I still haven’t found a good one yet (the cookie pictured was made by the Aunt herself). I have a star which I use with blueberry jelly for a Hannukah cookies and a shot glass which will do in a pinch. The idea is to have enough dough around the edge of the cookie that it can be handled without falling apart. I don’t care if the recipe says to make them equal, make more tops, especially on your first time. They break too easily. Also consider keeping the cut out hearts (if you have the cutter) and baking them. They are delightful as well.