Let me begin by saying this has nothing to do with Rise of the Guardians. I love that movie and will mention it several more times, but this is actually about an earlier version of that mythic character. These brain-thoughts are about Jack Frost. No, not the one with the dead dad. No, not that other one about the serial killer. This one made in 1979:
As a kid, I couldn’t get enough of this movie. I thought it was the funniest, coolest movie ever and as an adult, I have no idea why. When I watch it now, I just laugh at the sexism and the silliness of a time before children’s movies were made to entertain adults as well. I’ve seen it more on TV this year, than I ever did as a kid (due to Rise of the Guardians, which is a great film). I like to think that it was never that popular when I was a kid because of the blinding sexism, but it was probably because of the “sad” ending. Spoiler Alert: Jack doesn’t bang the chick.
I don’t know how recognizable this movie is to you modern kids, so I’ll give you the basic run down which neglects the groundhog because that freak never made any sense to me.
RUN DOWN:
Jack Frost is light-hearted fun-loving sprite who is invisible (Rise of the Guardians totally takes this idea, takes a flying leap, and make it a jaw-dropping depressing character motivation). He is one-of-a-kind, playful, can whistle up the wind, fly, and is invisible to humans which bothers him because he likes to play with them (sound familiar, Rise of the Guardians?). One of the residents in Jacks favorite town is Elisa (you know she’s the romantic lead because she doesn’t have an accent, unlike her parents and everyone else in her world). One day while Jack is stalking Elisa, she goes to play on a frozen lake with bunnies and squirrels and shit and suddenly, the villain, King of the Cossacks (once again late 70s) appears talks to himself through an iron puppet like a bat-shit crazy mofo, and makes the healthy decision to ride his iron horse over the ice. The ice breaks, nothing bad happens to the villain because it’s still early in the movie, and Elisa is about to go over a waterfall on a piece of ice (don’t worry the bunnies and shit are safe). Faced with her gruesome death, Jack Frost saves her by freezing the waterfall and flying her down to her furry friends (who seem to be taking bets on how she would die) Her reaction: “Oh that was fun!” (Rise of the Guardians did the ‘no dying horribly, we’re going to have some fun’ part of Jack Frost so much cooler). She calls him a hero and all the problems start.
Being called a hero put ideas in Jack’s head. He goes to Father Winter and begs to be made human through a very disturbing song. Winter says he can be a human but not a mooch. Jack’s got 3 to 4 months to get a house, a horse, a bag or gold, and a wife or he has to go back to being an overworked slave.
So Jack becomes human and sucks at it. Trips on ice. Forgets his name. Learns that he picked the worse place in the world to be a capitalist, because the King of the Cossacks will never let him have a house, horse, or gold. Now, he could conceivably go about working on the wife bit and make a convincing argument with Father Winter not to separate him from his beloved wife. Instead, he announces in the gayest way possible, “Kubblah Kraus has Got to be overthrown.”
So he tries to over throw him and he sucks. He only succeeds in getting the pretty girl close enough that the villain falls in love. After a heart-felt conversation with himself through his puppet, Bat-Shit Crazy kidnaps Elisa to woo her…but he’s going to wait just so he can ruin Christmas.
Okay, the King of the Cossacks kidnaps the girl. He totally carries her away on his horse to his castle in the snow. She doesn’t really fight him that hard. I can’t tell if it’s a result of bad animation or sexist storytelling, but I’ll move on.
You might expect this to be the part of the movie where Jack Frost uncovers his awesomeness and saves the girl thus proving his love for her and becoming her knight in golden armor, right? Nope. This is where the actual knight in golden armor shows up.
As evidenced by the fact that he gave her a real rose for Christmas and not an imaginary gift, Sir Ken Doll apparently banged Elisa in the past (or maybe just lived nearby). The knight takes on the entire army of iron men things and saves her. Her contribution is to run towards him with her arms outstretched (which is more useful than running away, I guess). Having saved her, Sir Ken Doll falls into the snow, inexplicably wounded through his undented armour (I guess that’ll show him to use a soft metal for protection against iron robots). He is taken away to be nursed back to health.
Oh, and Jack Frost, because he still sucks as a human, is captured. Bat-Shit Crazy announces, he is going to send a thousand iron men to kill everyone… because he wanted the girl or something… his motives are unclear. Jack has time to count each iron man as they march out before he goes back to being an invisible sprite and saves the day by whistling up “the storm of the century.” Buries the iron robots in the snow like zombies… well, twitching eclectic zombies… I like zombies and wanted to bring them in.
He makes it snow for just long enough that Elisa and Ken Doll fall in love (nursing-back-to-health is a valid dating strategy) and decide to get married at the “first blossom of spring.” At least she’s sad that her “sweet good little friend” has mysteriously disappeared (read: was killed brutally by the villain).
Eventually, through some freak roof accident, Kubblah Kraus is knocked out, Jack can imitate the villain’s iron puppet voice, and thus makes all the iron men go lemming over a cliff. Then Jack… either ducks or donkey kicks the King of the Cossaks out the window.
Jack then takes over. The castle is his house, the iron monstrosity is his horse, the peasant’s gold is his. All he needs is the woman and he’s a real boy forever. He goes to Elisa’s father (not her oddly) and finds out she is getting married to Sir Ken Doll. Jack is surprisingly unbitter about this, turns back into invisible sprite thing and kisses the bride as she walks out of the church, then flies off to bang either the Tooth Fairy or the Easter Bunny, depending on how you like your Fan Fiction (thanks again, Rise of the Guardians).
And that’s where the kvetching starts.
KVETCHING:
Well, not with the fan fiction… that’s just silly. Who would kvetch about fan fiction? The issues are with the not-happily-ever- after. I’ve noticed that a lot of my fellow uber-judgmental-ists have been remembering one of the characters from this film, Elisa, as a heartless bitch. Clearly, she comes from a place more evil than the Evil Queen from Snow White , the Evil Fairy in Sleeping Beauty, and the Evil Stepmother in Cinderella combined! How dare she leave the weird-looking nice guy in the friend zone and get her happily-ever-after on with some pretty boy in golden armor? The slut!
This is the reaction I’ve seen from modern adults taking about this movie out of nostalgia when they take their kids to see Rise of the Guardians. I’ve read it in forums, now and just to see how ingrained this happy ending thing is, I’ve talked up the movie with most of my friends and showed it to some that have never seen it. Including a pair of raging feminist lesbians. They still felt cheated at the end and thought poorly of Elisa, usually using disparaging sexual words (which is a strange thing we do to women; no matter her short coming we put it in terms of her physical appearance or sexual attitude, ever notice that?)
I am stunned 1) by anyone else who even knows this movie exists and 2) by how passionate people could get about a movie that they admitted was silly and out-dated. One of the main flaws people attribute to this movie is that she ends up with the Ken Doll and not Jack Frost. Jack doesn’t get the girl and that’s offensive somehow.
I’m getting more and more frustrated by this, because it’s totally not Elisa’s fault that she doesn’t end up with Jack Frost and what’s more, I think a good message to throw around in our children’s films sometimes is that love can’t be earned.
First off, to the point of Elisa being a bitch/slut/blonde/ whatever female slur applies to you: she is not a prize. Yes, she is a weak character. She does not save herself from danger (or even fight back). She waits for a literal knight in shining armor to do it for her, but that doesn’t make her the same as a house, horse, and gold. Those are things you can earn. Love is not.
From the beginning of the movie, she is in love with Sir Ken Doll. I know I’ve stripped him of the dignity of his name, but that fact that he has a cleft chin and perfect hair does not defeat the fact that she was totally in love with him before she ever really meets Jack “Snip”. And Jack Frost knows this.
While Jack is shameless eavesdropping, which is a perk of invisibility, he over hears this delightful tidbit.
Mama: You are so romantic, Elisa. Find yourself a good solid husband and settle down.
Elisa: I will. When my knight in golden armor comes along.
Her love is expressed in all the typical late 70’s clichés of children’s entertainment. She waits for him faithfully. He gives her roses. She nurses him back to health. He’s a knight.
Elisa marries the man she chooses which is shockingly progressive for this movie.
Secondly, and a lot of my friends missed this, Jack is a chauvinist who has the opinion that a woman is on par with house, horse, and gold.
Just after Elisa says she waiting for the knight in golden armor, Jack hears this:
Papa: Knights! Aren’t you in love with anybody yet?
Elisa (with a flippant laugh and toss of her clayish hand): Only Jack Frost.
At this expression of love, Jacks pointy hat jumps to attention (in no way is this a cartoon hard-on). But does he fly off to Father Winter at this point and beg for humanity so he can express his love to Elisa? No. He only thinks to pursue her after he’s saved her (earned her). As he sings to Father Winter to convince him he is lonely and in love, his fantasy is of Elisa’s serving him dinner!
Moreover, he never tells her the truth. He never says, I’m Jack Frost and I’ve come into human form out of love for you, which might have impressed her a little more than him failing to storm the castle. It’s really the only way out of the friend zone; she can’t be impressed by your sacrifices and gestures of affection if she doesn’t know you’re only doing them because you love her. For all Blondie knows, he is a tailor. Jack broke the first rule of all children’s role models which is to always tell the truth about who you are. Be yourself and all that crap (unless who you are is selfish or whiny, then you need to grow-up…but that’s not this movie).
Say, the first two points don’t matter. Elisa will marry the guy who saves her more, because that’s the logic of a late 70s romantic female. If she’s keeping count of the times she’s been saved. It goes Jack Snip: 0. Sir Ken Doll:1 (that we know of) and Jack Frost: 2. Clearly, to get his happy end in, Jack just had to tell her that he was Jack Frost and had earned her.
We, as an audience, feel like Elisa is a bitch for not ending up with Jack at the end, although she is clearly in love with another man and doesn’t really know Jack that well. We feel cheated because we know it was Jack Frost who saved both of them (and the entire town) when he sacrificed his humanity to become a spite and snow the iron soldiers in. I don’t think we’re keeping a subconscious tally of Jack versus Sir Ken. It’s out of compassion for the hero’s goals.
We sympathize with Jack’s loneliness (out-dated chauvinist prick that he is). We want him to be happy at the end and to accomplish his goal. He is a nice guy, he has made sacrifices, and damn it, the movie is about him. He has to get his happy-ending.
So we feel cheated of that goal accomplishment, when he doesn’t get the reward we see in every child’s film. Rudolph guides the sleigh and forgives years of bullying because he’s a celebrity now and there’s a girl reindeer who likes him. The Grinch is re-made into a modern film and now there a girl Who who likes him. The hero, [insert name of little boy/girl/old man/judge/skeleton], believes in Santa and discovers the true meaning of Christmas and there’s someone who likes him (you get a cookie if you followed all those movies). The weird-looking nice guy wins the beautiful woman’s heart.
But if Jack had married Elisa at the end and achieved all his life’s goals, he would have accomplished exactly what Kubblah Kraus would have. He would have stolen the woman away from the man she was in love with out of a sense that he deserved her. And we don’t really want that as an audience, do we?
Besides, Elisa is so sweet in the movie, she probably would have married him if he asked. Just to keep him human if that’s what he wanted. There might have been a weird threesome involved, since clearly both Sir Ken Doll and Jack were flamers. And come to think of it by lover-earning logic, Jack Frost won Sir Ken Doll too…but I’ve digressed into what if territory.